4734 Delmonte Avenue, Sarasota, FL — Investor special and fixer-upper on an oversized double lot in a non-deed-restricted Sarasota neighborhood with no HOA. This 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home features a dual primary floor plan with two en suite bedrooms, each with a private bath, a bay window living room, and a family room opening to a covered back porch and brick paver patio, plus a covered pavilion that creates a shaded outdoor retreat — the kind of space that could get used year-round in the Florida climate — all set behind a wide driveway with paver accents, connected with a breezeway and arched entry. The home also retains several ornamental architectural details — decorative elements, arched openings, and Mediterranean-influenced touches — that, with the right restoration effort, could be brought back to life and lean fully into a Spanish Mediterranean aesthetic that suits the Sarasota region beautifully. The property’s most compelling asset is a detached accessory structure with its own eat-in kitchen, living area, bedroom with a closet, full bath with a walk-in shower, private back patio, and a separately fenced yard. The building will require a thorough rehab and the addition of climate control before it can function as a guest cottage, rental unit, or additional living space — but the layout and footprint are already there, making it a strong candidate for the right buyer willing to put in the work. Alternatively, it could be converted back into a garage and workshop or repurposed in a number of other ways, depending on your needs and interests. The double lot provides ample room for a future pool or expanded outdoor living, and the absence of deed restrictions means boats and RVs are welcome on-site with no approvals required. Conveniently located near Longwood Park, Nathan Benderson Park, University Town Center, and the new Mote Marine Aquarium, with quick access to I-75, Sarasota International Airport, Downtown Sarasota, and the Gulf Coast beaches — this is a property with strong locational fundamentals and significant upside for the right buyer. Offered strictly as-is — which means what you see is what you get. Ready for a buyer who sees the opportunity. Per county records, the main house is 4-bed / 3-bath / 1,762 sq ft, air-conditioned. The 572 sq ft accessory structure is listed in the MLS both as a 2-car garage and as an in-law suite for search purposes, and is reflected in county records as 2 bed / 1 bath with no A/C — included in total recorded square footage. Buyers should verify all details independently.

Listing courtesy of CANDY SWICK & COMPANY (941) 376-9000



Listing information is provided by Participants of the Stellar MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Properties displayed may be listed or sold by various participants in the MLS Copyright 2026, Stellar MLS.
Last checked: 2026-04-12 05:50 AM EDT