Old Forest Lakes is a charming, established neighborhood in Sarasota offering spacious homes, mature landscaping, and a peaceful residential setting just minutes from downtown. Located southeast of the Bellevue Terrace area, this intimate enclave consists of approximately 72 homes positioned on generously sized lots surrounded by tropical greenery, lakes, and greenbelt spaces.
Buyers searching for Old Forest Lakes homes for sale are often drawn to its classic Florida character, central location, and strong long-term value.
Homes & Architectural Style
Development in Old Forest Lakes dates back to the 1950s, giving the neighborhood a timeless appeal. Many residences are traditional Florida ranch-style homes, while others have been updated to reflect Spanish or Mediterranean-inspired designs. Spacious interiors, large yards, and mature tree canopies contribute to the neighborhood’s comfortable, established feel.
Homes typically offer three-bedroom floor plans with practical layouts and inviting outdoor spaces. Because of the lot sizes and surrounding greenery, residents enjoy a sense of privacy not commonly found in newer subdivisions.
Setting & Lifestyle
The neighborhood is enhanced by natural surroundings including lakes, ponds, greenbelt corridors, and proximity to Phillippi Creek. Nearby Pinecraft Park and local golf facilities add recreational opportunities, while shaded streets lined with mature trees create a welcoming environment for families and long-time residents alike.
Although Old Forest Lakes is not a gated community, its layout and natural buffers provide privacy and quiet. The voluntary homeowners association fee helps support neighborhood events and community gatherings throughout the year.
Location & Nearby Attractions
Old Forest Lakes offers convenient access to Sarasota’s everyday amenities and cultural destinations. Local favorites such as Yoder’s Restaurant, Der Dutchman, and neighborhood shopping plazas are just minutes away. Downtown Sarasota is approximately a 15-minute drive, and the white sand beaches of Siesta Key are less than six miles from the neighborhood.
Old Forest Lakes Homes for Sale
Because of its established charm, central location, and limited number of homes, listings in Old Forest Lakes are relatively infrequent and often attract strong interest when available. View current Old Forest Lakes homes for sale below if inventory is active.
Old Forest Lakes FAQs
Where is Old Forest Lakes located?
Old Forest Lakes is located in Sarasota, just southeast of the Bellevue Terrace area and about 15 minutes from Downtown Sarasota.
How many homes are in the community?
The neighborhood consists of approximately 72 single-family homes.
What architectural styles are found in Old Forest Lakes?
Most homes are classic Florida ranch-style, with some updated to Spanish or Mediterranean-inspired designs.
Is Old Forest Lakes a gated community?
No. The community is not gated, but mature landscaping and greenbelt areas provide natural privacy.
Are there lakes in the neighborhood?
Yes. The community features ponds, lakes, and greenbelt spaces throughout.
Is there a homeowners association?
There is a voluntary homeowners association that collects a small annual fee to organize community events.
How close are the beaches?
Siesta Key beaches are less than six miles away, typically about a 15-minute drive.
Why is Old Forest Lakes desirable?
Its large lots, mature trees, central location, and established charm make it highly appealing to home buyers.
